articleIcon-icon

Article

7 min read

How to Measure ROI of Your Global Payroll System

Global payroll

Image

Author

Joanne Lee

Last Update

August 14, 2025

measure ROI of global payroll hero image
Table of Contents

Direct costs of global payroll

Indirect costs of global payroll

Metrics for measuring ROI of your global payroll

Increase ROI on your global payroll systems with Deel

Key takeaways
  1. Evaluating both direct and indirect costs allows you to accurately assess your payroll investment and measure ROI.
  2. Key metrics for measuring ROI of your global payroll system include total cost of ownership (TCO), payroll accuracy rates, compliance, employee satisfaction, and more.
  3. Deel helps businesses manage global payroll through a unified platform designed to automate repetitive tasks, ensure accuracy, and stay updated with the latest regulations.

Managing global payroll involves a variety of costs. From paying in-house staff and vendors to processing fees and tax payments, these expenses add up fast. How do you know whether the investment in your global payroll systems is worth it?

By tracking costs and using key metrics to evaluate the impact of your global payroll system, you can make strategic decisions on how to save time and money.

In this article, we’ll walk you through the direct costs, indirect costs, and metrics for measuring ROI of your global payroll system.

Direct costs of global payroll

Understanding the direct costs of global payroll is the first step in any ROI analysis. While some expenses are obvious, others may be hidden within your operations or overlooked when evaluating a new provider. Here’s a breakdown of common direct costs to account for:

Payroll provider fees

The most visible expense is what you pay your global payroll provider. These fees may include subscription costs, per-employee charges, implementation fees, support packages, and additional charges for premium features. While some platforms offer all-inclusive pricing, others charge separately for each country or service.

Banking and payment processing fees

Paying employees in multiple countries involves international wire transfers, currency conversions, and additional bank charges. If your payroll system isn’t integrated with multi-currency payment rails, you might be losing thousands annually to unfavorable exchange rates and hidden transfer fees.

In-house payroll staff

Even with a payroll provider, your HR and finance teams invest significant time in data entry, reconciliation, compliance monitoring, and issue resolution. The salaries and benefits for these staff members are a direct cost of your payroll operations, especially if processes are manual or require significant oversight.

Third-party vendors and local consultants

To stay compliant in every market, many companies rely on local accountants, legal advisors, or in-country partners. Each vendor relationship adds cost and complexity, particularly if your system isn’t centralized.

Compliance and regulatory costs

Every country requires timely filings, accurate tax payments, and local documentation. Failing to comply can result in hefty penalties. But staying compliant has a direct price tag too, including costs for things like payroll software and external legal counsel.

Forrester Total Economic Impact Study for Deel Global Payroll

Report

Discover the Total Economic Impact™ of Deel
The commissioned 2025 Forrester Total Economic Impact™ study interviewed Deel Global Payroll clients and found significant cost savings and payroll efficiencies. Read on to uncover the full impact.

Indirect costs of global payroll

Many businesses underestimate the indirect costs associated with a fragmented, manual, and outdated global payroll system. These hidden costs can have a significant impact on your bottom line, your reputation, and your ability to scale.

Payroll errors

Manual data entry and complex, multi-system processes increase opportunities for errors. Payroll errors can include over- or underpayment, incorrect tax withholdings, or misclassified employees. Each error takes hours to resolve and can lead to regulatory scrutiny or even lawsuits.

Moving from a decentralized to centralized payroll system helps mitigate these risks by consolidating payroll data and operations in one platform, ensuring consistency and accuracy.

Delayed payments

Late payments are more than an administrative headache. For employees, delayed pay can cause serious hardship and damage employee morale. For your business, it can trigger penalties, interest charges, and reputational damage. Timely payroll is critical for compliance and for maintaining trust with your workforce.

Compliance risks and fines

Global payroll compliance is a moving target. Payroll regulations change frequently, and even a minor oversight, such as missing a local filing deadline, can lead to fines or legal action. Indirect costs here can include penalties, back taxes, legal fees, and the opportunity cost of resolving issues instead of focusing on growth.

Reduced productivity

HR and finance teams bogged down in manual payroll tasks have less time for strategic initiatives. The cost of decreased productivity includes hours that could have been spent on recruiting, employee engagement, or financial analysis. Instead, teams spend more time chasing approvals or correcting errors.

Limited agility

If your payroll system can’t quickly adapt to new markets or handle rapid headcount changes, you risk missing out on growth opportunities. A slow, inflexible payroll system makes it more challenging to onboard and retain new talent, stay updated with local payroll regulations, and scale your overall business operations.

Employee turnover

Payroll errors and payment delays are among the top drivers of employee dissatisfaction, especially for remote or global teams. High turnover means higher costs for recruitment, onboarding, and lost resources. Your HR team will end up spending more time on filling empty roles rather than investing in making your current workforce stronger.

Global Hiring Toolkit
Employee Cost Calculator
Get a precise estimate of how much a potential global hire may cost from social security to injury insurance.

Metrics for measuring ROI of your global payroll

To accurately measure ROI on global payroll, you need to track the right metrics—ones that reflect efficiency, compliance, and employee experience in addition to cost. Here are the most important metrics to consider:

Total cost of ownership (TCO)

To determine your total cost of ownership, calculate the sum of all direct and indirect payroll costs. This number provides a baseline for comparing systems and evaluating savings after payroll implementation or switching providers. It’s also a good metric to keep an eye on in general as you manage your overall budget.

Payroll accuracy rate

Payroll accuracy rate is the percentage of pay cycles completed without errors. High accuracy reduces correction costs, boosts employee satisfaction, and minimizes compliance risk.

This is also a great way to keep an eye on any repeated errors throughout pay cycles and identify solutions. Outsourcing to a payroll provider can help automate this process and prevent errors.

Payment timeliness

Measure the percentage of employees paid accurately and on time, in every location you operate in. A high on-time rate is essential for compliance and workforce trust.

If you find that payment timeliness is lacking, your payroll may be bogged down by fragmented systems, complex approval workflows, or inaccurate employee data.

Compliance incident rate

Monitor the number and severity of compliance breaches, missed filings, or fines. A lower incident rate indicates a more effective system. A higher incident rate is not ideal, but this data still provides insight into your compliance risks and what you need to improve.

Payroll processing time

To get a better sense of payroll processing time, track the number of hours (or days) your HR and finance teams spend on each payroll cycle.

A high processing time reveals a need to streamline workflows, which may require a thorough payroll audit. By reducing your payroll processing time, you benefit from increased efficiency and lower labor costs.

Employee satisfaction

Conduct regular surveys and monitor support ticket trends related to payroll issues. While monitoring metrics regarding payroll operations can help you evaluate effectiveness on a technical level, surveying employees provides insight into the employee experience.

Satisfied employees are more likely to stay, which decreases recruitment costs and contributes to healthy company culture.

Cost per employee

Determine your cost per employee by dividing your total payroll cost by your total headcount. This metric helps you understand whether your system is scaling efficiently as you grow.

If your system is not built to support your global workforce, it may be time to consider sending out global payroll RFPs to find the expertise and support you need to scale.

Increase ROI on your global payroll systems with Deel

Measuring ROI of global payroll isn’t just about counting costs. It’s about gaining the payroll visibility, operational efficiency, and scalability to grow your business internationally. By understanding both the direct and indirect costs, tracking the right metrics, and choosing a reliable global payroll provider, you can optimize your payroll operations and unlock measurable returns.

Deel Global Payroll increases ROI by cutting payroll processing time by 60% with in-house expertise in 130+ countries and a unified platform to manage compliance, calculations, and reporting.

Book a demo with one of our experts to learn more about how Deel can partner with your business with flexible, scalable, and efficient global payroll solutions.

Deel Global Payroll
Truly simple, truly global payroll
Consolidate and streamline your international payroll operations. We’ll handle compliance, tax deductions and filings wherever you have entities—all supported by our team of in-house payroll experts.
Image

About the author

Joanne Lee is a content marketing professional with 6+ years of experience creating effective social, search, email, and blog content for companies ranging from start-ups to large corporations. She's passionate about finding creative ways to tell a purpose-driven story, staying active at the gym, and diversity and inclusion. At Deel, she specializes in writing about topics related to global payroll.